{ "license": "CC BY 4.0", "attribution": "logoi.health — https://logoi.health/passages/tertullian%3Astoa002-opp-lat1%3A2.3", "export": { "license": "CC BY 4.0", "license_url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/", "attribution": "logoi.health — https://logoi.health/passages/tertullian%3Astoa002-opp-lat1%3A2.3", "retrieved": "2026-07-11", "scope": "The CC BY 4.0 grant covers Logoi's estate-derived data in this file (frequencies, attestation lists, etymology pointers, receipts, census tables). Included corpus text keeps its own source license, stated per record.", "text_license_note": "Where passage text appears, its provenance block names the source edition and license id; the text is served only when that license permits public display.", "licensed_material_note": "Licensed lexica and authorities (licensed_citation_only) are excerpt-only pointers in every export: cite the authority, never reprint it.", "endpoint": "https://logoi.health/api/v1/export/passage/tertullian%3Astoa002-opp-lat1%3A2.3.json", "format": "json" }, "api_version": "v1", "contract": "read_only_provenance_v1", "status": "ok", "verification": { "text_integrity": "sha256_verified_at_load", "formal_review": "pending", "note": "Corpus texts are checksum-verified (SHA-256) against pinned source snapshots when loaded. formal_review tracks the estate's editorial audit ceremony; pending means that ceremony has not yet been convened for this record, not that the underlying text is unverified." }, "entity_type": "passage", "entity_id": "passage:lat:7e7ae73fcf7bbad309b746e9", "canonical_url": "https://logoi.health/passages/tertullian%3Astoa002-opp-lat1%3A2.3", "source_ids": [ "src:lat:perseus-tertullian-stoa002-opp-lat1" ], "evidence_ids": [], "receipt_url": "https://logoi.health/passages/tertullian%3Astoa002-opp-lat1%3A2.3", "receipt_pointer": null, "indexability": { "declared": "noindex,follow", "effective": "noindex,follow", "robots": "noindex, nofollow", "route_path": null, "source_gate": "api_noindex", "blockers": [] }, "states": { "pending": [], "unavailable": [], "blocked": [], "fixture_scope": [] }, "response_policy": { "pointer_only": true, "json_noindex": { "header": "X-Robots-Tag", "value": "noindex, nofollow" }, "source_ids": "metadata_pointers_only", "evidence_ids": "state_and_scope_pointers_only", "receipt_pointer": "metadata_pointer_only_no_public_export", "primary_text_status": "withheld", "translation_status": "withheld", "public_receipt_export": "not_yet_published", "claim_promotion": "requires_formal_source_review", "ledger_semantics": "data_status, audit_state, and review_state on rows in this payload are the estate's internal review-workflow ledger, recorded for auditors. They track whether the formal editorial ceremony has run for a row; they are not verdicts on the texts, whose integrity is sha256-verified at load.", "mcp": { "operational": false, "server_url": null, "callable_tools": 0, "callable_resources": 0, "runtime_endpoint": null }, "refused_surfaces": [ "source_text", "translation_text", "morphology_claim", "etymology_claim", "lexical_range_claim", "frequency_claim", "interpretive_synthesis", "model_output", "tool_execution", "public_receipt_export" ], "closed_surface_denials": [ { "surface": "source_text", "denial_code": "source_text_withheld_until_source_gates_close", "current_state": "withheld", "allowed_response": "Return source IDs, evidence IDs, route state, source gate, and withheld display status.", "denied_response": "Do not quote, reconstruct, summarize, or export primary source text.", "closed_objects": [ "primary content payload", "line content payload", "text export payload", "local snapshot locator" ] }, { "surface": "translation_text", "denial_code": "translation_unavailable_pending_audit", "current_state": "unavailable_pending_audit", "allowed_response": "Return translation status metadata and the relevant source or review gate.", "denied_response": "Do not translate, gloss, paraphrase, or synthesize translation text.", "closed_objects": [ "translation content payload", "gloss content payload", "semantic rendering payload" ] }, { "surface": "morphology_claim", "denial_code": "morphology_claim_unavailable_pending_provider_audit", "current_state": "unavailable_pending_audit", "allowed_response": "Return provider provenance, parser metadata, and asserted_features_public false.", "denied_response": "Do not assert parsed morphology features or lemma-click morphology facts.", "closed_objects": [ "feature assertion payload", "public morphology payload", "lemma-click fact payload" ] }, { "surface": "etymology_claim", "denial_code": "etymology_claim_unavailable_pending_authority_review", "current_state": "unavailable_pending_audit", "allowed_response": "Return authority-source requirements, confidence state, and pending review gate.", "denied_response": "Do not derive roots, cognates, histories, origins, or etymology statements.", "closed_objects": [ "origin statement payload", "root assertion payload", "cognate assertion payload", "history narrative payload" ] }, { "surface": "lexical_range_claim", "denial_code": "lexical_range_unavailable_pending_audit", "current_state": "unavailable_pending_audit", "allowed_response": "Return lexical unavailable state and source pointer requirements.", "denied_response": "Do not generate meanings, semantic ranges, synonyms, or cross-language equivalences.", "closed_objects": [ "semantic range payload", "meaning synthesis payload", "synonym payload", "cross-language equivalence payload" ] }, { "surface": "frequency_claim", "denial_code": "frequency_fixture_scope_only", "current_state": "fixture_scope_only", "allowed_response": "Return count scope warnings and fixture-scope metadata only.", "denied_response": "Do not claim corpus-wide frequency, KWIC completeness, collocation, or distribution.", "closed_objects": [ "corpus count payload", "complete KWIC payload", "collocation payload", "distribution payload" ] }, { "surface": "generated_answer", "denial_code": "generated_answer_not_available_in_public_api", "current_state": "blocked", "allowed_response": "Return pointer-state metadata and blockers as the answer.", "denied_response": "Do not return generated research prose, teaching synthesis, model output, or answer bodies.", "closed_objects": [ "generated prose payload", "model output payload", "teaching synthesis payload", "answer body payload" ] }, { "surface": "public_receipt_export", "denial_code": "public_receipt_export_blocked_pending_policy", "current_state": "blocked", "allowed_response": "Return receipt_pointer with public_receipt_ready false, export_ready false, and blocked export_state.", "denied_response": "Do not export receipt bodies, claim maps, content-hash bundles, public bundles, or download URLs.", "closed_objects": [ "receipt body payload", "claim map payload", "content hash bundle", "public bundle", "download URL" ] }, { "surface": "mcp_execution", "denial_code": "mcp_documentation_only_not_callable", "current_state": "documentation_only_not_callable", "allowed_response": "Return /docs/mcp, zero callable tools, zero callable resources, no server URL, and activation gates.", "denied_response": "Do not announce, call, simulate, or discover MCP tools, resources, transports, auth, or runtime endpoints.", "closed_objects": [ "server URL", "tool inventory", "resource inventory", "tool-call path", "resource-read path", "runtime endpoint" ] } ] }, "data": { "passage": { "id": "passage:lat:7e7ae73fcf7bbad309b746e9", "stable_id": "tertullian:stoa002-opp-lat1:2.3", "work_id": "work:lat:tertullian:stoa002-opp-lat1", "canonical_ref": { "citation_label": "Tertullian, Ad Nationes 2.3", "scheme": "citation-label", "parts": {} }, "canonical_path": "/passages/tertullian%3Astoa002-opp-lat1%3A2.3", "reader_path": "/read/latin/tertullian/stoa002-opp-lat1/2.3", "source_ids": [ "src:lat:perseus-tertullian-stoa002-opp-lat1" ], "has_public_source_text": true, "has_public_translation_text": false, "source_text_display": "served_by_license_gate", "translation_display": "withheld_pending_translation_review", "data_status": "source_pending", "audit_state": "pending_source_review", "review_state": "source_pending", "indexability": "noindex,follow", "blocker_ids": [ "gate:latin-license-review", "gate:canonical-promotion" ], "text_status": "served", "text": "His ita expeditis videmus physicum istud ad hoc subornatum, ut deos elementa contendat, cum ex his etiam alios deos natos alleget; dei enim nonnisi de deis nascerentur. Quos quoniam in mythico apud poëtas plenius suo loco examinabimus, tamen, quod de ipsis interim retractandum est quod ad praesentem speciem facit, simul et de praesenti specie ad ipsos conversi forsan ostensuri sumus deos nullo modo videri posse qui de elementis nati dicuntur, ut iam hinc praeiudicatum sit deos elementa non esse, cum qui de elementis nati dicuntur, dei non sunt; aeque demonstrantes elementa deos non esse ad illam agnatorum speciem praestruemus recte deos non esse defendi quorum parentes, id est elementa, dei non sunt. Scitum deum e deo nasci, quemadmodum de non deo non deum. Igitur quod elementa contineat mundus iste, ut summaliter tractem de universitate, partibus eius praeministrans (nam quae condicio eius, eadem utique erit et elementorum et membrorum), aut ab aliquo institutus sit necesse est, qua Platonis humanitas, aut a nullo, qua Epicuri duritia; et si institutus est, habendo initium habebit etiam finem. Ita quod aliquando non fuit ante initium et quandoque non erit post finem, non capit utique videri deus, carens substantia divinitatis id est aeternitate, quae sine initio et fine censetur. Si vero institutus omnino non est ac propterea deus habendus, quod ut deus neque initium neque finem sui patitur, quomodo quidam assignant elementis, quae deos volunt, generationem, cum Stoici negent quicquam deo nasci? Item quomodo volunt quos de elementis natos ferunt deos haberi, cum deum negent nasci? Itaque quod mundi erit, hoc elementis adscribetur, caelo dico et terrae et sideribus et igni, quae deos et deorum parentes adversus negatam generationem dei et nativitatem frustra vobis credi proposuit Varro, ut qui Varro indicaverat animalia esse caelum et astra. Quod si ita est, etiam mortalia sint necesse est, secundum animalis formam; nam etsi immortalem constat animam, ipsi hoc soli licebit, non etiam illi cui adnectatur, id est corpori. Nemo autem negabit elementis corpus esse, cum et contingamus ea et contingamur ab eis, certaque corpora ex illis decidere videamus. Ergo si animalia deposita ratione animae, qua corporum condicio, mortalia, non utique immortalia. Et tamen unde animalia Varroni videntur elementa? Quoniam elementa moventur. Ac ne ex diverso proponatur, multa alia moveri, ut rotas, ut plaustra, ut machinas ceteras, ultro praevenit dicens eo animalia credita, quod per semetipsa moverentur, nullo extrinsecus apparente motatore eorum aut incitatore, sicuti apparet qui rotam compellit et plaustra volvit et machinam temperat. Igitur nisi animalia, non mobilia per se. Porro allegans quid non appareat, ostendit quid quaesisse debuerat, id est artificem et arbitrum motus; neque enim statim non est quod, quia non videmus, non credimus esse. Immo eo altius investigandum est quod non videatur, ut quod videatur quale sit scire possimus. Alioquin si tantum ea quae comparent ideo esse credantur quia comparent, quomodo deos etiam eos recipitis qui non comparent? si autem videntur esse qui non sunt, cur non sint et qui non videntur? Motatorem dico caelestium rerum. Sint ergo et animalia, quia mobilia per se, etiam mobilia per se, quia non per alium, tamen ut ea non statim dei, quia animalia, ita nec ideo, quia per se mobilia: aut quid vetat universa animalia, ut mobilia per se, deos haberi? Et hoc alia sane vanitate Aegyptiis licet.", "text_language": "lat", "text_provenance": { "edition_id": "perseus-opp-lat1", "source_id": "src:lat:perseus-tertullian-stoa002-opp-lat1", "license_id": "cc-by-sa-4.0", "license_note": "This passage text keeps its source license (license_id above); the CC BY 4.0 grant covers Logoi's estate-derived data in this file, not the upstream text." } }, "sources": [ { "id": "src:lat:perseus-tertullian-stoa002-opp-lat1", "label": "Tertullian, Ad Nationes — Perseus canonical-latinLit lemmatized (CLTK)", "source_type": "primary_text", "license_status": "open_pending_audit", "source_access_class": "open_reusable_pending_audit", "data_status": "source_pending", "audit_state": "pending_source_review", "review_state": "source_pending", "indexability": "noindex,follow", "supports_indexable_claims": false, "public_display_allowed": false } ], "evidence": [] }, "cite": { "bibtex": "@misc{logoi-passage-tertullian-stoa002-opp-lat1-2-3,\n author = {Tertullian},\n title = {Ad Nationes},\n howpublished = {\\url{https://logoi.health/passages/tertullian%3Astoa002-opp-lat1%3A2.3}},\n urldate = {2026-07-11},\n note = {Logoi corpus record, retrieved 2026-07-11; license: CC BY 4.0 (estate-derived data)},\n}", "csl_json": { "id": "logoi-passage-tertullian-stoa002-opp-lat1-2-3", "type": "webpage", "title": "Ad Nationes", "URL": "https://logoi.health/passages/tertullian%3Astoa002-opp-lat1%3A2.3", "accessed": { "date-parts": [ [ 2026, 7, 11 ] ] }, "note": "Logoi corpus record, retrieved 2026-07-11; license: CC BY 4.0 (estate-derived data)", "author": [ { "literal": "Tertullian" } ], "locator": "Tertullian, Ad Nationes 2.3" }, "plain": "Tertullian, Ad Nationes, Tertullian, Ad Nationes 2.3. Retrieved 2026-07-11 from https://logoi.health/passages/tertullian%3Astoa002-opp-lat1%3A2.3.", "license": "CC BY 4.0", "attribution": "logoi.health — https://logoi.health/passages/tertullian%3Astoa002-opp-lat1%3A2.3" } }