{ "license": "CC BY 4.0", "attribution": "logoi.health — https://logoi.health/passages/tertullian%3Astoa007-opp-lat1%3A24", "export": { "license": "CC BY 4.0", "license_url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/", "attribution": "logoi.health — https://logoi.health/passages/tertullian%3Astoa007-opp-lat1%3A24", "retrieved": "2026-07-12", "scope": "The CC BY 4.0 grant covers Logoi's estate-derived data in this file (frequencies, attestation lists, etymology pointers, receipts, census tables). Included corpus text keeps its own source license, stated per record.", "text_license_note": "Where passage text appears, its provenance block names the source edition and license id; the text is served only when that license permits public display.", "licensed_material_note": "Licensed lexica and authorities (licensed_citation_only) are excerpt-only pointers in every export: cite the authority, never reprint it.", "endpoint": "https://logoi.health/api/v1/export/passage/tertullian%3Astoa007-opp-lat1%3A24.json", "format": "json" }, "api_version": "v1", "contract": "read_only_provenance_v1", "status": "ok", "verification": { "text_integrity": "sha256_verified_at_load", "formal_review": "pending", "note": "Corpus texts are checksum-verified (SHA-256) against pinned source snapshots when loaded. formal_review tracks the estate's editorial audit ceremony; pending means that ceremony has not yet been convened for this record, not that the underlying text is unverified." }, "entity_type": "passage", "entity_id": "passage:lat:57f3706cbd8245698e1404a4", "canonical_url": "https://logoi.health/passages/tertullian%3Astoa007-opp-lat1%3A24", "source_ids": [ "src:lat:perseus-tertullian-stoa007-opp-lat1" ], "evidence_ids": [], "receipt_url": "https://logoi.health/passages/tertullian%3Astoa007-opp-lat1%3A24", "receipt_pointer": null, "indexability": { "declared": "noindex,follow", "effective": "noindex,follow", "robots": "noindex, nofollow", "route_path": null, "source_gate": "api_noindex", "blockers": [] }, "states": { "pending": [], "unavailable": [], "blocked": [], "fixture_scope": [] }, "response_policy": { "pointer_only": true, "json_noindex": { "header": "X-Robots-Tag", "value": "noindex, nofollow" }, "source_ids": "metadata_pointers_only", "evidence_ids": "state_and_scope_pointers_only", "receipt_pointer": "metadata_pointer_only_no_public_export", "primary_text_status": "withheld", "translation_status": "withheld", "public_receipt_export": "not_yet_published", "claim_promotion": "requires_formal_source_review", "ledger_semantics": "data_status, audit_state, and review_state on rows in this payload are the estate's internal review-workflow ledger, recorded for auditors. They track whether the formal editorial ceremony has run for a row; they are not verdicts on the texts, whose integrity is sha256-verified at load.", "mcp": { "operational": false, "server_url": null, "callable_tools": 0, "callable_resources": 0, "runtime_endpoint": null }, "refused_surfaces": [ "source_text", "translation_text", "morphology_claim", "etymology_claim", "lexical_range_claim", "frequency_claim", "interpretive_synthesis", "model_output", "tool_execution", "public_receipt_export" ], "closed_surface_denials": [ { "surface": "source_text", "denial_code": "source_text_withheld_until_source_gates_close", "current_state": "withheld", "allowed_response": "Return source IDs, evidence IDs, route state, source gate, and withheld display status.", "denied_response": "Do not quote, reconstruct, summarize, or export primary source text.", "closed_objects": [ "primary content payload", "line content payload", "text export payload", "local snapshot locator" ] }, { "surface": "translation_text", "denial_code": "translation_unavailable_pending_audit", "current_state": "unavailable_pending_audit", "allowed_response": "Return translation status metadata and the relevant source or review gate.", "denied_response": "Do not translate, gloss, paraphrase, or synthesize translation text.", "closed_objects": [ "translation content payload", "gloss content payload", "semantic rendering payload" ] }, { "surface": "morphology_claim", "denial_code": "morphology_claim_unavailable_pending_provider_audit", "current_state": "unavailable_pending_audit", "allowed_response": "Return provider provenance, parser metadata, and asserted_features_public false.", "denied_response": "Do not assert parsed morphology features or lemma-click morphology facts.", "closed_objects": [ "feature assertion payload", "public morphology payload", "lemma-click fact payload" ] }, { "surface": "etymology_claim", "denial_code": "etymology_claim_unavailable_pending_authority_review", "current_state": "unavailable_pending_audit", "allowed_response": "Return authority-source requirements, confidence state, and pending review gate.", "denied_response": "Do not derive roots, cognates, histories, origins, or etymology statements.", "closed_objects": [ "origin statement payload", "root assertion payload", "cognate assertion payload", "history narrative payload" ] }, { "surface": "lexical_range_claim", "denial_code": "lexical_range_unavailable_pending_audit", "current_state": "unavailable_pending_audit", "allowed_response": "Return lexical unavailable state and source pointer requirements.", "denied_response": "Do not generate meanings, semantic ranges, synonyms, or cross-language equivalences.", "closed_objects": [ "semantic range payload", "meaning synthesis payload", "synonym payload", "cross-language equivalence payload" ] }, { "surface": "frequency_claim", "denial_code": "frequency_fixture_scope_only", "current_state": "fixture_scope_only", "allowed_response": "Return count scope warnings and fixture-scope metadata only.", "denied_response": "Do not claim corpus-wide frequency, KWIC completeness, collocation, or distribution.", "closed_objects": [ "corpus count payload", "complete KWIC payload", "collocation payload", "distribution payload" ] }, { "surface": "generated_answer", "denial_code": "generated_answer_not_available_in_public_api", "current_state": "blocked", "allowed_response": "Return pointer-state metadata and blockers as the answer.", "denied_response": "Do not return generated research prose, teaching synthesis, model output, or answer bodies.", "closed_objects": [ "generated prose payload", "model output payload", "teaching synthesis payload", "answer body payload" ] }, { "surface": "public_receipt_export", "denial_code": "public_receipt_export_blocked_pending_policy", "current_state": "blocked", "allowed_response": "Return receipt_pointer with public_receipt_ready false, export_ready false, and blocked export_state.", "denied_response": "Do not export receipt bodies, claim maps, content-hash bundles, public bundles, or download URLs.", "closed_objects": [ "receipt body payload", "claim map payload", "content hash bundle", "public bundle", "download URL" ] }, { "surface": "mcp_execution", "denial_code": "mcp_documentation_only_not_callable", "current_state": "documentation_only_not_callable", "allowed_response": "Return /docs/mcp, zero callable tools, zero callable resources, no server URL, and activation gates.", "denied_response": "Do not announce, call, simulate, or discover MCP tools, resources, transports, auth, or runtime endpoints.", "closed_objects": [ "server URL", "tool inventory", "resource inventory", "tool-call path", "resource-read path", "runtime endpoint" ] } ] }, "data": { "passage": { "id": "passage:lat:57f3706cbd8245698e1404a4", "stable_id": "tertullian:stoa007-opp-lat1:24", "work_id": "work:lat:tertullian:stoa007-opp-lat1", "canonical_ref": { "citation_label": "Tertullian, Adversus Praxean 24", "scheme": "citation-label", "parts": {} }, "canonical_path": "/passages/tertullian%3Astoa007-opp-lat1%3A24", "reader_path": "/read/latin/tertullian/stoa007-opp-lat1/24", "source_ids": [ "src:lat:perseus-tertullian-stoa007-opp-lat1" ], "has_public_source_text": true, "has_public_translation_text": false, "source_text_display": "served_by_license_gate", "translation_display": "withheld_pending_translation_review", "data_status": "source_pending", "audit_state": "pending_source_review", "review_state": "source_pending", "indexability": "noindex,follow", "blocker_ids": [ "gate:latin-license-review", "gate:canonical-promotion" ], "text_status": "served", "text": "Erant plane qui et tunc non intellegerent. Quoniam et Thomas aliquamdiu incredulus. Domine, inquit, non scimus quo eas, et quomodo viam novimus? Et Iesus: Ego sum via, veritas et vita: nemo venit ad patrem nisi per me; si cognovissetis me, cognovissetis et patrem; sed abhinc nostis illum, et vidistis illum. Et pervenimus iam ad Philippum, qui spe excitatus videndi patris, nec intellegens quomodo visum patrem audisset, Ostende, inquit, nobis patrem, et sufficit nobis. Et dominus: Philippe, tanto tempore vobiscum sum, et non cognovistis me? Quem dicit cognosci ab illis debuisse (hoc enim solum discuti oportet), quasi patrem, an quasi filium? Si quasi patrem, doceat Praxeas tanto tempore Christum cum eis conversatum patrem aliquando non dico intellegi, verum vel aestimari potuisse. Nobis omnes scripturae, et veteres Christum dei, et novae filium dei, praefiniunt. Hoc et retro praedicabatur, hoc et ab ipso Christo pronuntiabatur, immo iam et ab ipso patre coram de caelis filium profitente et filium glorificante: Hic est filius meus; et, Glorificavi, et glorificabo. Hoc et a discipulis credebatur, hoc et a Iudaeis non credebatur; hoc se volens credi ab illis omni hora patrem nominabat, et patrem praeferebat, et patrem honorabat. Si ita est, ergo non patrem tanto tempore secum conversatum ignoraverant, sed filium, et dominus, eum se ignorari exprobrans quem ignoraverant, eum utique agnosci volebat quem tanto non agnosci tempore exprobraverat, id est filium. Et apparere iam potest quo modo dictum sit: Qui me videt, videt et patrem, scilicet quo et supra: Ego et pater unum sumus. Quare? quia, Ego ex deo exivi et veni; et, Ego sum via; Nemo ad patrem venit nisi per me; et, Nemo ad me venit nisi pater eum adduxerit; et, Omnia mihi pater tradidit; et, Sicut pater vivificat, ita et filius; et, Si me cognovistis, et patrem cognovistis. Secundum haec enim vicarium se patris ostenderat, per quem pater et videretur in factis, et audiretur in verbis, et cognosceretur in filio, facta et verba patris administrante; quia invisibilis pater, quod et Philippus didicerat in lege, et meminisse debuerat: Deum nemo videbit, et vivet. Et ideo suggillatur patrem videre desiderans, quasi visibilem, et instruitur visibilem eum in filio fieri ex virtutibus, non ex personae repraesentatione. Denique si patrem eundem filium vellet intellegi dicendo, Qui me videt, patrem videt, quomodo subicit, Non credis quia ego in patre, et pater in me? Debuerat enim subiunxisse, Non credis quia ego sum pater? Aut quo exaggeravit, si non illud manifestavit quod voluerat intellegi, se scilicet filium esse? Porro dicendo, Non credis quia ego in patre, et pater in me, propterea potius exaggeravit, ne, quia dixerat, Qui me vidit, et patrem vidit, pater existimaretur, quod nunquam existimari se voluit, qui semper se filium et a patre venisse profitebatur. Igitur et manifestam fecit duarum personarum coniunctionem, ne pater seorsum quasi visibilis in conspectu desideraretur, et ut filius repraesentator patris haberetur. Et nihilominus hoc quoque interpretatus est, quomodo pater esset in filio, et filius in patre. Verba, inquit, quae ego loquor vobis, non sunt mea, utique quia patris; pater autem manens in me facit opera. Per opera ergo virtutum et verba doctrinae manens in filio pater per ea videtur per quae manet, et per eum in quo manet, ex hoc ipso apparente proprietate utriusque personae, dum dicit, Ego sum in patre, et pater in me. Atque adeo, Credite, ait. Quid? Me patrem esse? Non puto scriptum esse, sed, Quia ego in patre, et pater in me, si quo minus, vel propter opera credite, ea utique opera per quae pater in filio, non visu, sed sensu videbatur.", "text_language": "lat", "text_provenance": { "edition_id": "perseus-opp-lat1", "source_id": "src:lat:perseus-tertullian-stoa007-opp-lat1", "license_id": "cc-by-sa-4.0", "license_note": "This passage text keeps its source license (license_id above); the CC BY 4.0 grant covers Logoi's estate-derived data in this file, not the upstream text." } }, "sources": [ { "id": "src:lat:perseus-tertullian-stoa007-opp-lat1", "label": "Tertullian, Adversus Praxean — Perseus canonical-latinLit lemmatized (CLTK)", "source_type": "primary_text", "license_status": "open_pending_audit", "source_access_class": "open_reusable_pending_audit", "data_status": "source_pending", "audit_state": "pending_source_review", "review_state": "source_pending", "indexability": "noindex,follow", "supports_indexable_claims": false, "public_display_allowed": false } ], "evidence": [] }, "cite": { "bibtex": "@misc{logoi-passage-tertullian-stoa007-opp-lat1-24,\n author = {Tertullian},\n title = {Adversus Praxean},\n howpublished = {\\url{https://logoi.health/passages/tertullian%3Astoa007-opp-lat1%3A24}},\n urldate = {2026-07-12},\n note = {Logoi corpus record, retrieved 2026-07-12; license: CC BY 4.0 (estate-derived data)},\n}", "csl_json": { "id": "logoi-passage-tertullian-stoa007-opp-lat1-24", "type": "webpage", "title": "Adversus Praxean", "URL": "https://logoi.health/passages/tertullian%3Astoa007-opp-lat1%3A24", "accessed": { "date-parts": [ [ 2026, 7, 12 ] ] }, "note": "Logoi corpus record, retrieved 2026-07-12; license: CC BY 4.0 (estate-derived data)", "author": [ { "literal": "Tertullian" } ], "locator": "Tertullian, Adversus Praxean 24" }, "plain": "Tertullian, Adversus Praxean, Tertullian, Adversus Praxean 24. Retrieved 2026-07-12 from https://logoi.health/passages/tertullian%3Astoa007-opp-lat1%3A24.", "license": "CC BY 4.0", "attribution": "logoi.health — https://logoi.health/passages/tertullian%3Astoa007-opp-lat1%3A24" } }